EL DORADO HILLS, El Dorado County — November 11, 2026. Residents of the Heritage El Dorado Hills neighborhood who have challenged the brightness of nearby pickleball court lighting for years have won a significant step toward removing the fixtures. CBS Sacramento reported November 11 that a judge signed off on a settlement agreement providing for removal of the 50-foot-tall lights installed at the park.
Why residents took the dispute to court
Homeowner Corde Wagner told CBS that light from the park required blackout window coverings in his home. George Steed, another resident involved in the challenge, argued that the district should have addressed residents' concerns and the permitting process before installing the structures. Their complaints are attributed to the interviewees and lawsuit; allegations in litigation are not automatically findings of every disputed fact.
Residents began raising the problem after the installation in 2022. CBS Sacramento's contemporaneous 2022 reporting described objections from people living near the park. The current case shows why public outreach and actual nighttime light-spill measurements can matter even when a sports facility serves a community need.
What does the settlement actually cost?
According to CBS's review of court documents, the lights cost approximately $200,000 to install and are estimated to cost another $75,000 to remove. Those are reported project and projected removal figures, not a verified final expenditure or proof that a single contractor has been paid both amounts. The El Dorado Hills Community Services District board was scheduled to consider approval of the agreement Thursday, November 12. California58 has not confirmed the board's final action or a date on which physical removal will occur.
The district's response
Community Services District president Noelle Mattock told CBS the agency's focus is implementing the agreement while continuing to provide a park for the community. That is an acknowledgment of the settlement process, not a promise that every park use or lighted activity will continue unchanged.
What needs to happen next?
- Will the district publish the executed settlement, board action and final construction/removal schedule?
- Which agency will verify safe electrical disconnection, foundation removal and site restoration?
- What was the total taxpayer cost of litigation, installation, permitting, legal counsel and removal?
- How will nighttime and daytime sports use be managed if the lights are dismantled?
- What public consultation or measurable light-spill standards will be required before similar park lighting is considered in the future?
Original video and sources
Video: CBS Sacramento, Steve Large, November 11 report, including interviews and views of the park. The footage remains on the broadcaster's platform; California58 has not authenticated a matching YouTube ID to use as the hero. A verified district meeting recording would also help document the final public decision.
Sources: CBS Sacramento, November 11, 2026 and earlier CBS March 2022 coverage. Court documents and official responses welcome at California58.
Support El Dorado Hills News
Choose how to support El Dorado Hills News:
Credit / Debit Card via StripeChoose your contribution amount on the secure California58 Stripe checkout. One-time support for independent local journalism.
Continue with PayPal Continue with ZelleZelle payments go to Vitaly Ataev Troshin. Please verify the recipient in your bank before sending. Availability depends on your bank.
Optional reader support. When possible, add “El Dorado Hills News” to the payment note. Contributions are not advertised as tax-deductible. Support does not influence editorial decisions.More from El Dorado Hills News
- El Dorado Hills Assistant Admits Stealing Nearly $18 Million: Federal Guilty Plea Details Luxury Purchases →
- El Dorado Hills Library Closes November 11 for Veterans Day, Offers 3D Printing and Book Clubs →
- El Dorado Hills Town Center Plans November 21 Holiday Makers Market and Evening Art Event →
- El Dorado Hills Fire Board Sets November 19 Public Meeting at Station 85 →
- El Dorado Hills Sharpshooter Infestation to Be Discussed at November 13 County Workshop →
COMMUNITY
Comments
Join the California58 conversation. You must be signed in to comment.
Create a free California58 account or sign in with an available social provider.